United Kingdom verdict (TL;DR)
Verified 2026-05-08UK payroll is a HMRC RTI (Real Time Information) market, every employer running PAYE must submit RTI on each payroll run, and vendor depth and reliability vary significantly. Among global products: Rippling launched Rippling UK in 2023 with native HMRC RTI and pension auto-enrolment; ADP UK runs significant UK payroll volume; Deel handles UK contractor and EOR payroll well; QuickBooks Payroll has a credible UK product. Gusto, OnPay, Paychex, Paycom, Paycor, Justworks are essentially absent from the UK. The dominant UK installed base is locally-built: IRIS Staffology, Sage Business Cloud Payroll, BrightPay, Moorepay, Xero Payroll UK, MHR iTrent, Pegasus Opera 3 collectively run the majority of UK payroll workloads.
Picks for United Kingdom
- UK tech-forward firms wanting HRIS + IT + Payroll unified: Rippling Rippling UK launched 2023; native HMRC RTI, pension auto-enrolment, NEST/NOW/People's Pension/Smart Pension integration. Best fit for 50-500 employee UK tech.
- UK enterprise wanting outsourced full-service payroll: ADP ADP UK runs significant UK enterprise payroll volume. Native HMRC RTI, deep UK compliance ops, dedicated specialists.
- UK SMB already running QuickBooks Online UK: QuickBooks Payroll UK-localised version with HMRC RTI, NIC, pension auto-enrolment. Tightest GL sync to QuickBooks UK accounting. Best fit when QB is already the accounting system.
- UK contractor and EOR payroll: Deel Strong UK contractor management, IR35-aware, umbrella company integrations (Parasol, Giant). Best fit when paying UK contractors from a non-UK entity or via EOR.
- UK SMB-to-mid (5-200 employees), usually right answer: Local champion (IRIS Staffology, Sage Payroll, BrightPay) See local challengers below. Globals beyond Rippling/QuickBooks rarely fit UK SMB. IRIS Staffology, Sage Business Cloud Payroll, BrightPay, or Moorepay will usually be the right answer.
How the payroll software market looks in United Kingdom
UK payroll is shaped by HMRC RTI (Real Time Information), every employer running PAYE must submit RTI on every payroll run via FPS (Full Payment Submission) and EPS (Employer Payment Summary). Vendor RTI depth, reliability, and HMRC certification status vary significantly. UK payroll also requires NIC (National Insurance Contributions) employer + employee, pension auto-enrolment (Pensions Act 2008) into NEST, NOW: Pensions, The People's Pension, Smart Pension, or alternative qualifying scheme, statutory leave (28 days incl. bank holidays, SSP, SMP/SPP/SAP, shared parental leave), and IR35 / off-payroll working rules for contractor payments via intermediaries.
The global products that fit UK payroll are narrow. Rippling launched Rippling UK in 2023 with native HMRC RTI, NIC, pension auto-enrolment, and statutory leave defaults, credible for 50-500 employee UK tech. ADP UK runs significant UK enterprise payroll volume. QuickBooks Payroll has a credible UK product (HMRC RTI, NIC, pension auto-enrolment) for QuickBooks Online UK customers. Deel handles UK contractor and EOR payroll well. Gusto, OnPay, Paychex, Paycom, Paycor, and Justworks are essentially absent from the UK, they have no UK entity, no HMRC RTI capability, no pension auto-enrolment integration.
The dominant UK installed base is locally-built. IRIS Staffology (IRIS Software, ~25,000 UK customers), Sage Business Cloud Payroll (Sage UK, dominant in UK SMB and accountant ecosystem), BrightPay (Bright HR, ~120,000 UK businesses), Moorepay (Zellis-owned, large UK mid-market and enterprise), Xero Payroll UK (Xero UK SMB), MHR iTrent (UK enterprise and public sector), and Pegasus Opera 3 (UK Mittelstand) collectively run the majority of UK payroll workloads. UK accountants and bookkeepers strongly drive payroll vendor choice, IRIS, Sage, BrightPay, and Xero are the four ecosystems UK accountants know best.
HMRC RTI (Real Time Information), every UK employer running PAYE must submit FPS (Full Payment Submission) on each payroll run, plus EPS (Employer Payment Summary) monthly. RTI is high-stakes; HMRC penalties for late or incorrect filings are aggressive. HMRC-recognised vendors only, confirm vendor is on HMRC's recognised payroll software list. NIC (National Insurance Contributions), employer + employee, with rates and thresholds set annually in Spring Budget. Pension auto-enrolment (Pensions Act 2008), automatic enrolment of qualifying employees into a workplace pension; vendor must integrate with NEST, NOW: Pensions, The People's Pension, Smart Pension, or alternative qualifying scheme. Statutory leave: 28 days incl. bank holidays, SSP (Statutory Sick Pay), SMP (Statutory Maternity Pay), SPP (Statutory Paternity Pay), SAP (Statutory Adoption Pay), Shared Parental Leave/Pay, plus the new Carer's Leave 2024. Apprenticeship Levy (0.5% of pay bill above £3M annual) requires accurate calculation. CIS (Construction Industry Scheme) for construction subcontractors requires CIS300 monthly returns. P11D / P11D(b) annual benefits-in-kind reporting. Real Living Wage and National Minimum Wage / National Living Wage (rates change annually April). IR35 / off-payroll working rules apply to medium and large UK businesses hiring contractors via intermediaries; Bullhorn and Workday handle natively, payroll vendors handle umbrella-company payments. UK GDPR + DPA 2018 govern employee data; data residency questions matter post-Brexit.
Quick comparison, ranked for United Kingdom
| Product | Best for | Starts at | 10-emp/mo* | Pricing | G2 | Geo |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Rippling | Tech-enabled SMBs and mid-market with IT/HR overlap | $35 + $8/emp | $115 | 4.8 | United States +3 | |
| 3 ADP (RUN & Workforce Now) | Every segment, but strongest at 50–5,000 | Quote | - | 4.1 | United States +1 | |
| 6 QuickBooks Payroll | QuickBooks-using small businesses | $45 + $6/emp | $105 | 4.0 | United States | |
| 9 Deel | Companies with cross-border workforce | $49/emp | $490 | 4.6 | 150+ countries | |
| 1 Gusto | Small businesses, startups, professional services firms | $49 + $6/emp | $109 | 4.5 | United States | |
| 4 Paychex Flex | Traditional small and mid-market businesses | $39 + $5/emp | $89 | 4.2 | United States | |
| 7 Paycom | Mid-market with HCM consolidation goal | Quote | - | 4.2 | United States | |
| 8 Paycor | Mid-market across healthcare, manufacturing, hospitality | Quote | - | 4.0 | United States | |
| 5 OnPay | US small businesses, niche industries (restaurants, farms, nonprofits) | $49 + $6/emp | $109 | 4.8 | United States | |
| 10 Justworks | Small businesses and venture-backed startups in supported states | $50 + $8/emp | $130 | 4.6 | United States (PEO availability varies by state) |
*10-employee monthly cost = base fee + (per-employee × 10) using the lowest published tier. For opaque-pricing vendors, no value is shown.
What buyers in United Kingdom actually pay
Median annual deal size by employee band, in GBP. Crowdsourced from anonymized buyer disclosures.
| Product | Employee band | Median annual (GBP) | Sample | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rippling | 50-200 employees | £24,500 | 41 | HRIS + UK Payroll bundle, GBP-billed |
| ADP (RUN & Workforce Now) | 500-2,000 employees | £145,000 | 31 | UK Workforce Now equivalent |
| QuickBooks Payroll | 5-25 employees | £850 | 78 | QuickBooks Payroll Standard, UK |
| Deel | UK contractor pool, 10-50 contractors | £22,500 | 62 | Contractor management + payments |
United Kingdom-built or United Kingdom-strong vendors worth knowing
Not yet ranked in our global top 10, but credible options for United Kingdom buyers and worth a shortlist.
IRIS Staffology
Visit ↗IRIS Software-owned. ~25,000 UK customers. The dominant UK accountant-recommended payroll. HMRC-recognised, native pension auto-enrolment with NEST/NOW/People's Pension/Smart Pension.
Sage Business Cloud Payroll
Visit ↗Sage UK. Dominant in UK SMB and accountant ecosystem. HMRC-recognised, deep accountant integration via Sage Accounting.
BrightPay
Visit ↗Bright HR-owned (Bright). ~120,000 UK businesses. Affordable UK SMB payroll (£114-£199/year per employer, unlimited employees). HMRC-recognised, strong support.
Moorepay
Visit ↗Zellis-owned. Large UK mid-market and enterprise outsourced payroll. ~10,000 UK customers. Fits 100-2,000 employee UK firms wanting outsourced payroll bureau model.
Xero Payroll UK
Visit ↗Xero UK SMB. Bundled with Xero Accounting. £5/month + £0.30/employee. Best fit for UK SMB already running Xero.
MHR iTrent
Visit ↗MHR UK enterprise. Dominant in UK public sector, NHS trusts, large councils, retail majors. Strong workforce management for hourly workforces.
Pegasus Opera 3
Visit ↗Pegasus Software UK. Traditional UK Mittelstand payroll-accounting suite. Works for UK 50-500 employee firms wanting integrated payroll + accounting.
KashFlow Payroll
Visit ↗IRIS-owned UK SMB payroll. £5+/month. Built for UK SMB and accountants.
Global picks that don't fit here
- GustoNo UK payroll capability. US-only.
- OnPayNo UK payroll capability. US-only.
- Paychex FlexNo UK payroll capability. US-only.
- PaycomNo UK payroll capability. US-only single-database HCM.
- PaycorNo UK payroll capability. US-only.
- JustworksPEO model is US-only. Not relevant for UK buyers.
All 10, ranked for United Kingdom
Same intelligence as the global ranking, vendor trust, review patterns, verified pricing, compliance, reordered for the United Kingdom market.
Rippling
Payroll, HR, and IT on a single workforce graph.
Rippling is the most architecturally ambitious product in this category. By treating employees as a single object that drives payroll, devices, identity, app access, and benefits, Rippling can do things no traditional payroll vendor can, like provisioning a laptop and Slack account the moment a hire signs their offer letter, then deprovisioning everything when payroll terminates them. The cost: a modular pricing model where the bill grows quickly as you add capabilities, and an opaque base fee that you only learn from a sales call.
Tech-forward companies of 25–500 employees that want HR, payroll, and IT to share a single data model.
Bootstrap small businesses that just need clean payroll, or companies that prefer transparent published pricing.
Strengths
- Unified workforce graph, single source of truth for HR, payroll, IT (devices, SSO, app provisioning), and finance
- Global payroll in 50+ countries via Rippling Global and EOR via Rippling EOR (separate add-ons)
- 90-second payroll runs after initial setup; touted as the fastest in the industry
- Strongest device management integration; can lock or wipe a laptop directly from the termination workflow
- 600+ integrations; sets the bar for the category
- Robust permissions system with granular role-based access control suitable for mid-market
Weaknesses
- Mandatory base platform fee (~$35/month) plus per-module per-employee fees stack up quickly, total cost often 2–3x Gusto for similar payroll-only use
- Pricing is fully opaque; no published rates for any module
- Implementation is more complex than Gusto or OnPay; expect 2–4 weeks for a 50-person company
- Sales-driven buying motion can feel pushy; 1+ year contracts are common
- Support quality varies by tier; entry customers report slower response than enterprise
- Founder Parker Conrad's prior involvement with Zenefits is a reputational consideration for some buyers
Pricing tiers
opaque- Base platform (Unity)Required foundation; HRIS only$35+$8 /mo +/emp
- Payroll moduleAdd-on; US payroll, tax filing, direct deposit$8 /emp/mo
- Benefits administrationAdd-on$6 /emp/mo
- Time trackingAdd-on$4 /emp/mo
- App management (IT)Add-on; SSO, app provisioning$8 /emp/mo
- Device management (IT)Add-on; MDM$8 /emp/mo
- Global payroll / EORCountry-specific pricingQuote
- · Implementation fees can apply for companies over 100 employees
- · EOR pricing typically $500–$700/employee/month, negotiable at scale
- · Modules cannot be paid for in isolation; the base platform is mandatory
Key features
- +Unified employee record across HR, payroll, IT, finance
- +Global payroll in 50+ countries
- +Native device (MDM) and app (IDP) management
- +Workflow automation across all modules
- +Custom reporting on the workforce graph
- +90-second payroll runs
- +EOR for hiring without legal entity
ADP (RUN & Workforce Now)
The category-defining incumbent; deepest compliance bench.
ADP processes payroll for one in six US workers, which is both its biggest strength and its biggest weakness. The compliance and tax-filing infrastructure is unmatched: ADP files in jurisdictions most competitors have never heard of and has dedicated specialists for niche regulatory situations. The flip side is a product portfolio that feels like the result of decades of acquisitions glued together, RUN for small business, Workforce Now for mid-market, Vantage HCM and Lyric HCM for enterprise, each with different UX and overlapping features.
Companies where compliance and reliability outweigh UX, regulated industries, multi-state operations, 100+ employees.
Tech-forward small businesses that value transparent pricing and modern UX, or companies under 25 employees with simple needs.
Strengths
- Deepest tax and compliance coverage of any vendor, files in jurisdictions others outsource
- Dedicated payroll specialists assigned to mid-market and enterprise accounts
- Strong year-end (W-2, 1099, ACA) processing reliability, rarely a missed deadline
- ADP Marketplace has 700+ pre-built integrations
- Global payroll via ADP GlobalView / Celergo for true enterprise multinationals
- Robust benefits administration including retirement plan administration in-house
Weaknesses
- Pricing is fully opaque; nearly every customer overpays without aggressive negotiation
- UX feels dated compared to Gusto and Rippling; mobile apps lag desktop in features
- Long contracts (1–3 years) with steep early termination penalties ($1,500–$3,000 reported)
- Cross-product UX inconsistency between RUN, Workforce Now, and enterprise tiers
- Sales process is high-touch and slow; expect 3–6 weeks to close even for SMB
- Implementation fees are typically charged separately and can reach $1,500–$10,000
Pricing tiers
opaque- RUN EssentialSmall business, basic payroll + tax filingQuote
- RUN EnhancedAdds garnishment, background checks, state new-hire reportingQuote
- RUN CompleteAdds HR helpdesk and HR forms libraryQuote
- Workforce Now Essential / Enhanced / PremiumMid-market HCM tiersQuote
- · Implementation fees of $1,500–$10,000+ depending on complexity
- · W-2 generation may incur per-employee fees on lower tiers
- · Early termination fees on multi-year contracts
- · Per-state filing fees in some configurations
Key features
- +Multi-state and multi-EIN tax filing
- +Garnishment processing
- +New-hire state reporting
- +Time and attendance (separate module)
- +Benefits administration
- +Retirement plan administration
- +ACA reporting and management
- +Background checks and onboarding
QuickBooks Payroll
The default if you already run QuickBooks Online.
QuickBooks Payroll exists for one reason: native integration with QuickBooks Online. If your accounting lives in QBO, this is the only payroll product where the GL sync is truly seamless, every payroll run posts to the right accounts automatically with no mapping errors. If you don't use QuickBooks, almost every alternative on this list is a better product.
Businesses that already run QuickBooks Online and want zero-friction GL integration.
Companies on Xero, NetSuite, or any non-Intuit accounting stack, the value proposition mostly evaporates.
Strengths
- Native, real-time GL sync with QuickBooks Online, best of any payroll product
- Same-day direct deposit on Premium and Elite tiers (no extra fee on Elite)
- Auto Payroll runs salaried payroll automatically
- Tax penalty protection on Elite tier, Intuit pays IRS penalties up to $25,000/year
- Established brand: most accountants are already trained on the product
- Workers comp integration via AP Intego
Weaknesses
- Pricing has increased ~30% over the past three years; $45–$125/mo + per-employee
- Standalone (not bundled with QBO) it lacks the modern UX of Gusto or OnPay
- Customer support quality has declined consistently in recent reviews; long phone holds
- Benefits administration is thinner than Gusto or OnPay
- No native time tracking, separate QuickBooks Time subscription required
- Limited HR functionality compared to even basic Gusto Plus tier
Pricing tiers
public- CoreFull-service payroll, next-day direct deposit, auto tax filing$45+$6 /mo +/emp
- PremiumSame-day direct deposit, HR support center, expert review$80+$9 /mo +/emp
- EliteTax penalty protection, project tracking, white-glove setup$125+$11 /mo +/emp
- · QuickBooks Online subscription separate ($35–$235/mo)
- · QuickBooks Time (formerly TSheets) for time tracking: separate subscription
- · Promotional pricing (50% off 3 months) reverts to full price automatically
Key features
- +Native QuickBooks Online integration
- +Auto Payroll
- +Same-day direct deposit (Premium+)
- +Tax penalty protection (Elite)
- +Multi-state tax filing
- +Mobile app payroll
- +Workers comp via AP Intego
- +1099 contractor payments
Deel
Global contractor and EOR payroll, in 150+ countries.
Deel exists in the US payroll conversation because a growing share of US companies hire contractors and employees abroad. It is the category-leading product for both contractor management ($49/contractor/month flat) and Employer of Record (EOR), where Deel acts as the legal employer in countries where you have no entity. Deel also offers global payroll for companies that already have entities. For US-only domestic payroll, Deel is not your first pick, but it has no peer for cross-border hiring.
Companies hiring contractors or full-time employees outside the US, especially without local legal entities.
US-only businesses with all-domestic employees, Gusto, OnPay, or Rippling are better fits.
Strengths
- Contractor management in 150+ countries with localized contracts and tax forms
- EOR (Employer of Record) service in 100+ countries, hire abroad without setting up a legal entity
- Multiple payment methods including local bank transfer, crypto, and Wise
- Dedicated in-country compliance specialists for every supported country
- Background checks, equipment provisioning, and immigration support add-ons
- Strong API for engineering teams that want to programmatically manage contractor lifecycle
Weaknesses
- EOR pricing of $599/employee/month is steep; volume discounts to $350–$500 require 20+ employees
- Cross-currency FX markup of 0.6–2% on payments is meaningful at scale
- US domestic payroll product (Deel US Payroll) is newer and less mature than US-focused competitors
- Country-specific surcharges of $50–$150 stack on top of base fees
- 2024 controversy around founder dispute and corporate espionage allegations remains a brand consideration
- Customer support quality has been reported as variable; some customers report long ticket-resolution times
Pricing tiers
public- Contractor ManagementPer contractor/month; includes contracts, payments, tax forms$49 /emp/mo
- Global PayrollFor companies with own entities; $1,000 setup per country$29 /emp/mo
- EOR (Employer of Record)Negotiable to $350–$500 at 20+ employees$599 /emp/mo
- US PayrollNewer offering for domestic US$19+$19 /mo +/emp
- Deel HRFree HRIS for up to 200 employees$0+$0 /mo +/emp
- · FX markup of 0.6–2% on cross-currency payments
- · Country surcharges of $50–$150 in some jurisdictions
- · One-time deposit (typically one month salary) for EOR
Key features
- +Contractor management in 150+ countries
- +EOR in 100+ countries
- +Global payroll for owned entities
- +Localized contracts and tax forms
- +Crypto and multi-currency payments
- +Visa and immigration support
- +Background checks
- +Equipment provisioning (laptops shipped globally)
Gusto
The default payroll platform for modern small businesses.
Gusto is the most-recommended payroll platform for US businesses with 1–50 employees and the rare product that earns near-unanimous praise from accountants and end users alike. It handles full-service payroll, automated tax filing in all 50 states, contractor payments, benefits, and basic HR, all behind one of the cleanest interfaces in B2B software. The trade-off: Gusto is US-only, scales awkwardly past ~100 employees, and the Premium plan is overkill for most.
US-based small businesses with 1–75 employees that want a clean, modern payroll experience with no surprises.
Multi-country teams, businesses with complex HR workflows (succession planning, performance management), or anyone above 200 employees.
Strengths
- Full-service tax filing (federal, state, local) included even on the entry Simple plan, many competitors charge extra for multi-state
- Setup completes in under 30 minutes for a small business with no prior payroll system
- Unlimited payroll runs at no extra cost; auto-pilot mode runs payroll on schedule without manual intervention
- 180+ integrations including QuickBooks, Xero, Gusto-native time tracking, and most major 401(k) providers
- Built-in health insurance broker in 38 states; you can shop and enroll plans from inside Gusto
- Contractor payments at $6/contractor/month with no base fee for contractor-only plans
Weaknesses
- No native global payroll, international employees require Gusto Global (powered by partners) at extra cost
- Reporting is shallow compared to Paycor or ADP; complex GL mapping requires workarounds
- Customer support quality has declined per recent G2 reviews; phone hold times of 20+ minutes reported in 2026
- Weak fit for companies above ~100 employees with multi-entity, multi-EIN structures
- Premium plan ($180 base) adds dedicated CSM and HR resource center but most features are available on Plus
Pricing tiers
public- SimpleSingle state, full-service payroll, basic benefits$49+$6 /mo +/emp
- PlusMulti-state, time tracking, PTO management, project tracking$80+$12 /mo +/emp
- PremiumDedicated CSM, HR resource center, compliance alerts$180+$22 /mo +/emp
- Contractor OnlyNo base fee; pay only for contractors$0+$6 /mo +/emp
- · 401(k) administration via Guideline integration: $39 + $8/participant/month
- · Workers comp insurance: variable by carrier
- · Health benefits: pass-through premium; Gusto charges no broker fee
Key features
- +Automated multi-state tax filing
- +Same-day or 2-day direct deposit (Plus+)
- +Auto-pilot payroll
- +Contractor 1099 generation
- +Built-in health benefits marketplace
- +PTO and time tracking (Plus+)
- +Employee self-onboarding
Paychex Flex
Traditional payroll with modernized self-service.
Paychex is ADP's closest peer, a 50+ year incumbent that processes payroll for ~740,000 US businesses. The Flex platform is the modern web/mobile front-end on top of decades of payroll infrastructure. The dedicated-rep model is the central differentiator: every Paychex customer gets a named payroll specialist, which appeals to owners who want a phone number to call rather than a chatbot.
Owners of 10–250 person companies who want a named human contact and prefer phone-based service over self-serve.
Tech-forward teams that prefer self-service or anyone allergic to opaque mid-tier pricing.
Strengths
- Dedicated payroll specialist assigned to every account, not just enterprise
- 24/7 US-based phone support included on Select tier and above
- Strong PEO offering (Paychex PEO) with state-specific compliance handled
- Solid retirement (401(k)) administration with $0 setup promotion frequently available
- Integrated time and attendance, hiring, and HR services
- Acquisition-driven feature breadth: Paychex owns SurePayroll (small biz), Advance Partners (factoring), and others
Weaknesses
- Only Essentials pricing is published ($39 + $5/employee); higher tiers require custom quote
- UX feels dated; mobile app reviews trail Gusto and Rippling
- Annual contract auto-renewal with early termination fees of $1,500–$3,000 reported
- Year-end W-2 fees may be charged separately on lower tiers
- Implementation typically requires 2–4 weeks; not a same-week setup
- Customer reviews report inconsistent rep quality, some excellent, some require escalation
Pricing tiers
partial- EssentialsPublished pricing; basic payroll, tax filing, employee self-service$39+$5 /mo +/emp
- SelectAdds dedicated specialist, employee benefits enrollmentQuote
- ProAdds HR services, applicant trackingQuote
- EnterpriseCustom enterprise HCMQuote
- · W-2 fees on Essentials tier
- · QuickBooks integration may require add-on
- · Time and attendance is a separate module
- · Early termination fees on annual contracts
Key features
- +Multi-state tax filing
- +Dedicated payroll specialist
- +24/7 US-based support (Select+)
- +PEO option with state-by-state compliance
- +401(k) administration in-house
- +Time and attendance
- +Applicant tracking (Pro+)
- +Workers comp pay-as-you-go
Paycom
Single-database HCM with employee-driven payroll.
Paycom's differentiator is Beti® (Better Employee Transaction Interface), employees themselves verify and approve their paycheck before payroll is processed, which the vendor claims reduces errors significantly. The whole platform sits on a single database, so HR, payroll, time, and benefits genuinely share data instead of syncing across modules. The catch: Paycom is sold exclusively through high-touch direct sales, contracts run multi-year, and the buying experience can feel coercive.
Mid-market companies (50–2,000 employees) that want a single-vendor HCM and value employee-driven payroll accuracy.
Anyone under 50 employees, anyone who wants to evaluate without sitting through a sales cycle, or anyone needing global payroll.
Strengths
- Beti® shifts paycheck verification to employees, reducing post-payroll corrections
- Single-database architecture, true data unity vs. integrated modules
- Strong mobile employee experience; high mobile-adoption rates reported
- Comprehensive HCM: payroll, HR, talent acquisition, talent management, time, benefits in one product
- Built-in expense management, learning management, and survey tools
- Public company with stable financials; low risk of vendor disappearance
Weaknesses
- Pricing is fully opaque; ~$25–$36/employee/month for full HCM, $12–$18 payroll-only (industry estimates)
- Implementation fee typically 15–35% of first-year subscription
- Multi-year contracts (often 3+ years) with stiff early termination penalties
- Sales tactics frequently flagged as aggressive in customer reviews
- UX is functional but feels enterprise-ish; not a delight
- Best-fit only above ~50 employees; small businesses overpay for unused capability
Pricing tiers
opaque- Payroll onlyIndustry estimate $12–$18 PEPM$15 /emp/mo
- Full HCMIndustry estimate $25–$36 PEPM$30 /emp/mo
- · Implementation fee 15–35% of first-year subscription
- · Multi-year contract terms
- · Some advanced modules (LMS, survey) priced separately
Key features
- +Beti® employee-driven payroll verification
- +Single-database HCM architecture
- +Talent acquisition (ATS)
- +Performance management
- +Time and attendance
- +Benefits administration
- +Learning management
- +Mobile-first employee app
Paycor
Mid-market HR specialist with strong people analytics.
Paycor was a top-three independent mid-market HCM vendor before being acquired by Paychex in early 2025. The product remains separately marketed and continues to compete head-to-head with Paycom and ADP Workforce Now. Paycor's historical strength is the depth of its people analytics and HR workflows; the trade-off is implementation that runs longer than Gusto or OnPay and pricing that isn't public.
Mid-market companies (50–1,000 employees) in healthcare, manufacturing, or hospitality that want HR workflow depth.
Small businesses under 25 employees, or anyone wanting transparent published pricing.
Strengths
- Strong people analytics dashboard with predictive turnover and pay-equity reporting
- Robust talent management: performance reviews, 1:1s, OKRs, learning paths
- Industry-vertical expertise in healthcare, manufacturing, restaurants, and nonprofit
- Paycor Smart Sourcing (recruiting) is well-rated for outbound candidate sourcing
- Acquired by Paychex in 2025, providing financial stability and broader resources
- Granular role-based permissions suitable for multi-location operations
Weaknesses
- Pricing not publicly disclosed; quotes vary widely based on rep negotiation
- Time tracking and accounting integrations often add $2–$8 per employee per month
- Setup fees of $50–$100 reported for accounting integrations
- Implementation typically takes 4–8 weeks for mid-market deployments
- Post-Paychex acquisition strategy is still settling; some uncertainty about long-term roadmap
- Customer support quality is mixed, strong CSMs but inconsistent tier-1 response
Pricing tiers
opaque- BasicPayroll + tax filingQuote
- EssentialAdds onboarding, document managementQuote
- CoreAdds analytics dashboardQuote
- CompleteAdds talent managementQuote
- · Time tracking integrations: $2–$8/employee/month
- · Accounting integration setup: $50–$100
- · Multi-year contracts common
Key features
- +People analytics with predictive insights
- +Multi-state tax filing
- +Performance management
- +Recruiting (Paycor Smart Sourcing)
- +Learning management
- +Time and attendance
- +Benefits administration
- +Compensation planning
OnPay
Transparent flat pricing; everything-included payroll.
OnPay is the rare payroll vendor with one plan and no upsells. At $49/month + $6/employee, every customer gets full-service payroll, multi-state filing, integrated HR tools, benefits administration, and customer support. There are no Plus or Premium tiers gated behind enterprise sales calls. For US small businesses that want predictability and dislike the modular-upsell model, OnPay punches well above its market share.
US small businesses (1–50 employees) that want everything included with no surprise fees and dislike enterprise-style sales tactics.
Mid-market or enterprise teams with complex HR workflows, or companies needing global payroll.
Strengths
- Single transparent plan: $49 base + $6/employee, same price for 1 or 500 employees
- No multi-state filing fees, unlimited monthly payroll runs, no setup fees
- Industry-specific support for restaurants, farms, nonprofits, churches, and dental practices
- Health, dental, vision, and retirement (401k) integrated; OnPay is a licensed broker in all 50 states
- White-glove migration: OnPay sets up your account from prior provider data at no charge
- Strong G2/Capterra ratings (4.8/4.9) with low complaint volume
Weaknesses
- Brand recognition is much lower than Gusto, ADP, or Paychex, fewer accountants pre-recommend it
- Integration count (~80) is far below Gusto (180) or Rippling (600)
- No native time tracking; relies on integrations (When I Work, Deputy, QuickBooks Time)
- No global payroll; US-only
- Mobile app is functional but not a differentiator
- Reporting is solid but not as deep as Paycor or ADP
Pricing tiers
public- OnPay (single plan)All features; no tiers, no upsells$49+$6 /mo +/emp
- · Health/dental/vision premium passthrough; OnPay charges no broker fee
- · 401(k) admin via Vestwell or Guideline integration: variable
Key features
- +Multi-state tax filing (no per-state fees)
- +Unlimited payroll runs
- +Integrated benefits admin (broker in all 50 states)
- +Industry-specific tax handling (clergy, ag, nonprofit, restaurant tip credit)
- +Free historical data migration
- +Multiple pay rates and pay schedules
- +Garnishment processing
- +HR document library and templates
Justworks
PEO that gives small businesses Fortune 500 benefits.
Justworks is a PEO (Professional Employer Organization), which means you co-employ your team with Justworks for tax and benefits purposes. The economic logic: by pooling thousands of small businesses, Justworks gets large-group health insurance pricing that an individual 10-person company could never access on its own. For founders who care about offering competitive benefits to attract talent, the PEO model often pays for itself in lower premiums. The constraint: PEOs aren't the right fit for every state or every business model.
Venture-backed startups and small businesses (5–50 employees) that want premium benefits without HR overhead.
Companies that want to keep benefits selection in-house, anyone in a PEO-restricted state, or businesses over ~150 employees where in-house benefits become economical.
Strengths
- Large-group health insurance access via Aetna and UnitedHealthcare on PEO Plus tier
- State unemployment insurance and workers comp included; Justworks handles all filings
- 24/7 customer support with Slack-style messaging interface
- Compliance burden largely lifted, Justworks files state, federal, and local payroll taxes
- Built for venture-backed startups that need benefits to recruit
- Newer Payroll-only plan ($50 + $8/employee) for businesses that want Justworks UX without PEO commitment
Weaknesses
- PEO model is materially more expensive than DIY payroll, $59–$109/employee/month vs. $6–$15 for non-PEO
- You give up some control: Justworks is the employer of record for tax purposes
- Not available in all states for all PEO services (check state-by-state coverage)
- Less customization than Rippling or Paycom; you live within Justworks' opinionated workflows
- Health insurance plan options are curated; you can't bring your own broker or carrier on PEO Basic
- Exiting a PEO is non-trivial; mid-year exits require careful tax planning
Pricing tiers
public- PayrollStandalone payroll, no PEO; tax filing and HR tools included$50+$8 /mo +/emp
- PEO BasicPEO with payroll, tax filing, compliance, workers comp, 401(k)$59 /emp/mo
- PEO PlusAdds Aetna/UnitedHealthcare health, dental, vision, HSA/FSA, life, disability$109 /emp/mo
- · Health insurance premiums passed through (member responsibility)
- · COBRA administration on PEO tiers
- · State-by-state PEO availability varies
Key features
- +PEO co-employment model
- +Large-group health benefits access
- +Workers comp included
- +401(k) administration
- +24/7 messaging support
- +Multi-state tax filing
- +Compliance dashboards
- +Standalone Payroll plan option
Frequently asked questions
The questions buyers actually ask before they sign.
Why aren't IRIS, Sage, BrightPay, or Xero in your top 10?
Rippling UK vs Sage Business Cloud Payroll for UK 100-500 employee tech?
Can I run UK payroll from Gusto, OnPay, or Paychex?
How does IR35 affect UK payroll choice?
What's the difference between a payroll service and a PEO?
How much should I budget for payroll software?
How long does it take to switch payroll providers?
Do I need full-service tax filing or can I file myself?
Is QuickBooks Payroll worth it if I don't use QuickBooks?
Can my payroll software handle multi-state employees?
What about international employees and contractors?
How do I evaluate payroll software without sitting through a sales demo?
Final word
Looking at a different market? See the global Payroll Software ranking, or pick another country at the top of this page.
Last updated 2026-05-08. Local pricing reverified quarterly. Found something inaccurate? Tell us.